Page 1 of 1
NEW CAR WHICH ONE
Posted: Sun Apr 24, 2005 12:32 pm
by gordysmit
please help me pic one. Moveing soon I want a new car 3 years warranty needed and you have got to look at that i will be doing 20k a year .So which one to pick and which one will lose more money
Posted: Sun Apr 24, 2005 4:38 pm
by carmadaaron
TBH its really down to what make/style/looks you are after,
Seat seems to be the sportier part of VW,
IMO the 9n2 doesnt look that good

, if i had a choice now, it will prob be the Ibiza FR , thats 160brake isnt it? while the other 2 are 130?
Posted: Sun Apr 24, 2005 5:12 pm
by Nelson_Wilbury
carmadaaron wrote:
if i had a choice now, it will prob be the Ibiza FR , thats 160brake isnt it? while the other 2 are 130?
No, the FR is 130bhp TDi, the Cupra is 160bhp TDi.
Just buy a Cupra, if you buy an FR, you'll only be kicking yourself 3 months down the line for not getting one.
Posted: Sun Apr 24, 2005 5:38 pm
by gordysmit
May be but you will have to take in to considertion the car will be doing 20/25k year in miles and i dont want to lose that much money in 3 years time [ quote="Nelson_Wilbury"]
carmadaaron wrote:
if i had a choice now, it will prob be the Ibiza FR , thats 160brake isnt it? while the other 2 are 130?
No, the FR is 130bhp TDi, the Cupra is 160bhp TDi.
Just buy a Cupra, if you buy an FR, you'll only be kicking yourself 3 months down the line for not getting one.[/quote]
Posted: Sun Apr 24, 2005 7:18 pm
by Nelson_Wilbury
If you don't want to loose that much money, your probably better off skipping the new car idea altogether

and getting something about 6 months old that has already lost the bulk of its money.
Out of the FR, GT and VRS, the VRS will probably hold its value better.
Posted: Sun Apr 24, 2005 8:47 pm
by toXXin
It's a shame you won't consider used, as my Ibiza would be a great little car!
The Fabia is the best put together, but has white seats and 5 doors, so I was put off. If you don't mind 5 doors and can get some Scotchguard, get the Fabia. If you are like me and couldn't live with it, buy the Ibiza.
Posted: Sun Apr 24, 2005 9:38 pm
by gordysmit
Nelson_Wilbury wrote:If you don't want to loose that much money, your probably better off skipping the new car idea altogether

and getting something about 6 months old that has already lost the bulk of its money.
Out of the FR, GT and VRS, the VRS will probably hold its value better.
just looking at a skoda vrs and there £11500 black with xeons that what i want but looking at new and there only £12000 ish from driveadeal.com
Posted: Sun Apr 24, 2005 10:33 pm
by dxg
I'd say go for the Skoda. The Polo's overpriced to start with (even more so when you see it doesn't have traction control) and I think the Seat will suffer the most from depreciation irrespective of its greater inital power.
Just my 2p. Too early to really tell, though.
Deek.