Have i been given the right advice?

Chat about your MKI or MKII Polo (86 and 86F)
Post Reply
WildChild
Silver Member
Posts: 259
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 5:20 pm
Location: Norwich

Have i been given the right advice?

Post by WildChild »

I've gone to 3 different places and they all will NOT fit anything bigger than 165/75 13s on my Polo MK1..

I was told by lots of people that 175/50 13s would fit..

also.. 165/75s would be fine.. and a place near me has offered me a full set of 4x 165/75 13s GoodYear tyres + fitting is £156.00

what you reckon?
NornIron
Bronze Member
Posts: 197
Joined: Thu Mar 24, 2005 3:42 am
Location: County Down...

Post by NornIron »

What wheels are you using, standard 4.5J steels?
WildChild
Silver Member
Posts: 259
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 5:20 pm
Location: Norwich

Post by WildChild »

145R13 5"

although new tyres will be going on 5.5" alloys.
NornIron
Bronze Member
Posts: 197
Joined: Thu Mar 24, 2005 3:42 am
Location: County Down...

Post by NornIron »

OK, here's the boring technical stuff...

175/50 x 13's will safely fit a rim between 5 and 6.5J, however due to the lower rolling radius of the tyre, your speedo will not register your true speed. Compared to the standard 145/80 x 13's fitted to a Mk1, if you fit 175/50 x 13's your speedo will register 70mph when you are actually travelling at 62.9mph :?

165/75 x 13's will safely fit a rim between 4.5 and 6J, however in this case the rolling radius of the new (165/75) tyre is slightly higher, meaning your speedo will register 70mph when you are actually travelling at 71.93mph :oops:

You also need to consider any potential safety issues; a rim that is too narrow in relation to the tyre width will allow the tyre to distort excessively sideways under fast (!) cornering.

On the other hand, unduly wide rims on an ordinary car tend to give rather a harsh ride because the sidewalls have not got enough curvature to make them flex over bumps and potholes. I don't know if 175's scrub on a Mk1, but I'm sure someone on here will know!

Finally, steering weight...the wider the tyre, the heavier the steering when parking!

I don't know if any of this is of help to you...but it's certainly food for thought!
SteB
Silver Member
Posts: 280
Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2004 8:48 am
Location: North Yorkshire

Post by SteB »

NornIron wrote: On the other hand, unduly wide rims on an ordinary car tend to give rather a harsh ride because the sidewalls have not got enough curvature to make them flex over bumps and potholes. I don't know if 175's scrub on a Mk1, but I'm sure someone on here will know!
I ran 175/50s on a 5.5" rim and lowered 40mm for about 7k miles and never had a single rubbing incident, even on cattle grid jumps! :oops:
polock
Getting There!
Posts: 95
Joined: Mon Mar 14, 2005 8:09 am
Location: York
Contact:

Post by polock »

I have 165/65/13's on my mk1 golf gti alloys pitted to the polo with 40mm lowering and ive had no adverse effects, rubbing etc.

I have to be aware tho that my speedo isnt exactly right lol
Mk2Adam
Platinum Member
Posts: 1311
Joined: Sat Jun 04, 2005 6:58 pm
Location: Kent

Post by Mk2Adam »

sorry but i couldn't be bothered to use any calculator thingamy jigs to see why they're saying they can't do it.....but my tyres are 185/60/13 on my mk2 hatch with no scrubbage....as i said i havn't checked any calculators but that 165/75 tyre doesn't sound right, my original tyres were 145/80 so you're going 2 stages wider and only 1 smaller profile, but as i said that's compared to my tyres so prob best to check it in comparison to you're orignal wheels :)
Post Reply